Reformation Through Organization
By Austin Taylor Stevens
“The fact is, that given the challenges we face, education doesn't need to be reformed -- it needs to be transformed." He goes on to say in an exert from his book, The Element, "the key to this transformation is not to standardize education, but to personalize it, to build achievement on discovering the individual talents of each child, to put students in an environment where they want to learn and where they can naturally discover their true passions". The ways in which to transform education are in the way curriculum is taught and organized, how should classes be selected for students, and in what way are students to be taught.
In most schools, teachers are required to write a lesson plan beforehand and send it to their supervisors for review. After approval teachers do exactly what the plan dictates without room for change in the field of study or even student input on a given subject. Freire, in "The banking model of education talks about student was viewed as an empty account to be filled by the teacher. He notes that "it transforms students into receiving objects.” He refers to education in its current condition as, “education thus becomes an act of depositing, in which the students are depositories and the teacher is the depositor." (says on page 4) “Schools do not account for individuality, mainstream public (USA or state school UK) schooling is a product of industrialization of the people. Freire believed that high school classes were being taught for the majority of subjects with only one correct answer which he believed isn't the best way to layout a class. Sir Robinson in his, “Schools Kill Creativity”, talks about how schools project through their teaching that only the logical used idea is the right one and that creative ones won't work. Most teachers don't change what is going to happen to classes during the classes, if a class doesn’t understand a certain subject; instead of moving on they should stop and continue `working on it until the concept is understood. Every required science class has to cover x amounts of subjects regardless of the students and their abilities. If a class is full of students who thoroughly enjoy the subject they will go through it faster, but if the class doesn't care it will drag on slowly. The fact that teachers have to cover these subjects may seem ancient and annoying to the students and they will lose students interests along the way. When asked about high school, most students almost always have a major negative learning experience, no matter where the student is from. Throughout history, when new technologies are introduced they are accepted without changing how they are to be used. For example, when firearms became more widespread, armies used the tactic of walking up to the other army and then fight leading to high number of causalities which proved that old tactics are ineffective when used with new technology. Schools today are using old tactics of teaching to combat today's students and problems. If educational systems today are unable to adapt to changes now, they will continue in a downward spiral of neglecting to offer students their own creative thoughts, and problem solving. There needs to be a forced change to the educational system to become something that is more personalized. In the movie, “The Freedom Writers”, Mrs. Gruwell changes the material that was to be taught in her class because she realized that the lesson plan she had was not going to work with this group of students. She also realized she needed to become more open and be able to connect with her students. I believe a class curriculum should define what the class is about and the main goal of what the objective is to teach. I also feel that individual parts of the class should be broad in order to teach the type of students or to be able to make adjustments to the student plan. For example, in history you can say world history but you also should include in the curriculum, the parts of history that affect the students. A change in curriculum is required to make education better but curriculum isn’t the only thing that is needed to be repaired.
When a new student is enrolled into a high school, they are given four or five classes that are required and usually one class that is an elective. Schools nowadays are used to teach a broad basis of subjects to prepare them for basic work fields or for moving on to a university for more learning. Students are given the idea that it their elective is a free class a class to do whatever they want for fun. In a lot of cases the elective classes are either taken up by an academic required classic like foreign languages or an academic positive class such as musical instrumentation. For a majority of the student population there elective class is now taken away.. They are not given any options to take classes that would be considered for work related future careers. John Taylor Gatto, in his work article, “Against School” states, “school train children to be employers and consumers; teach your own to think critically and independently." In a recent discussion I had with a cosmetology student, she talked about how she was unable to pick any classes that would relate to her future career in cosmetology while still in high school. There are students who want certain careers that are not usually looked upon as normal careers. Cosmetology is a major industry in the United States, and yet most high schools do not have a program supporting it. A major problem that I have seen in high schools is that when students have a plan of what they would like to do with their lives, with a career in mind, the high schools will not support it. Take the example of a student who wants to become a physicist but still has to take required arts and general history classes, or an art major still is required to take physics or a math class. There are many students who yearn to be an active part in their education and not be lumped into cookie cutter classes. If it wasn't for radical thinkers who strayed away from the norm, we wouldn't have such great and terrible inventions that have change the world. Deciding how classes are to be assigned to students by career choices, needs, and individuality is just again another piece that affects the problem in our education system. There is still one last thing that needs to be overhauled in order to make it a truly revolutionary change that would make it all the better and that change is how students are taught.
Teaching is difficult thing, but to prepare our students for a better tomorrow we must teach our students in a much more efficient manner to prepare them for the challenges that lie before them. Instead of teaching our students childish material we should prepare them with useful skills instead of meaningless knowledge. A good example of this I found was during, Ken Robinson’s Ted talk named, "Education Kills Creativity". He talks about how, “difficult it is to teach children nowadays that we are going to go into a world that we cannot possibly understand what is to come.” I think about all the changes in my lifetime, and the different problems that have come up all over the world these past seventeen years. Change is always happening whether it happens in science, technology or world wars. Teaching adaptation in the school systems must be a priority because we have to prepare them for an enhanced diverse and flexible future. Educators should be taught how to adapt to the changes in technology and the changes in our culture and apply them to educational systems to better connect with students and prepare them for a better learning system, just like how different armies adapted to new technologies and warfare and used it to win battles. As previously stated in Gatto, we must appeal to creativity and independent thinking otherwise we fall into the trap of being afraid of isolation and unable to be at peace with their own selves.
If we do not change, our students will not be educated and not be productive members of our future and we can stop this course of industrialization to our children. It will be difficult to change the way our classrooms work and how the schooling system operates overall. People will want to go back to the old form of education claiming that it is better but, if it was truly better we wouldn't have problems with it. Ken Robinson, John Taylor Gatto, Paolo Freire, and many other educators all agreed that change is needed. For this to happen, all three of the main ideas I have written about must work together. To reach a new era in the world, education must change.
Works Cited
Freire, Paulo. Pedagogy of the Oppressed. New York: Continuum, 2000. Print.
Gatto, John. "Against School - John Taylor Gatto." Against School - John Taylor Gatto. N.p., n.d. Web. 20 Mar. 2014.
Rose, Mike. "I Just Wanna Be Average." Web log post. Http://userwww.sfsu.edu/mmartin/rose.pdf. N.p., n.d. Web. 18 Mar. 2014.
"TED: Ideas worth Spreading." TED: Ideas worth Spreading. N.p., n.d. Web. 20 Mar. 2014.
By Austin Taylor Stevens
“The fact is, that given the challenges we face, education doesn't need to be reformed -- it needs to be transformed." He goes on to say in an exert from his book, The Element, "the key to this transformation is not to standardize education, but to personalize it, to build achievement on discovering the individual talents of each child, to put students in an environment where they want to learn and where they can naturally discover their true passions". The ways in which to transform education are in the way curriculum is taught and organized, how should classes be selected for students, and in what way are students to be taught.
In most schools, teachers are required to write a lesson plan beforehand and send it to their supervisors for review. After approval teachers do exactly what the plan dictates without room for change in the field of study or even student input on a given subject. Freire, in "The banking model of education talks about student was viewed as an empty account to be filled by the teacher. He notes that "it transforms students into receiving objects.” He refers to education in its current condition as, “education thus becomes an act of depositing, in which the students are depositories and the teacher is the depositor." (says on page 4) “Schools do not account for individuality, mainstream public (USA or state school UK) schooling is a product of industrialization of the people. Freire believed that high school classes were being taught for the majority of subjects with only one correct answer which he believed isn't the best way to layout a class. Sir Robinson in his, “Schools Kill Creativity”, talks about how schools project through their teaching that only the logical used idea is the right one and that creative ones won't work. Most teachers don't change what is going to happen to classes during the classes, if a class doesn’t understand a certain subject; instead of moving on they should stop and continue `working on it until the concept is understood. Every required science class has to cover x amounts of subjects regardless of the students and their abilities. If a class is full of students who thoroughly enjoy the subject they will go through it faster, but if the class doesn't care it will drag on slowly. The fact that teachers have to cover these subjects may seem ancient and annoying to the students and they will lose students interests along the way. When asked about high school, most students almost always have a major negative learning experience, no matter where the student is from. Throughout history, when new technologies are introduced they are accepted without changing how they are to be used. For example, when firearms became more widespread, armies used the tactic of walking up to the other army and then fight leading to high number of causalities which proved that old tactics are ineffective when used with new technology. Schools today are using old tactics of teaching to combat today's students and problems. If educational systems today are unable to adapt to changes now, they will continue in a downward spiral of neglecting to offer students their own creative thoughts, and problem solving. There needs to be a forced change to the educational system to become something that is more personalized. In the movie, “The Freedom Writers”, Mrs. Gruwell changes the material that was to be taught in her class because she realized that the lesson plan she had was not going to work with this group of students. She also realized she needed to become more open and be able to connect with her students. I believe a class curriculum should define what the class is about and the main goal of what the objective is to teach. I also feel that individual parts of the class should be broad in order to teach the type of students or to be able to make adjustments to the student plan. For example, in history you can say world history but you also should include in the curriculum, the parts of history that affect the students. A change in curriculum is required to make education better but curriculum isn’t the only thing that is needed to be repaired.
When a new student is enrolled into a high school, they are given four or five classes that are required and usually one class that is an elective. Schools nowadays are used to teach a broad basis of subjects to prepare them for basic work fields or for moving on to a university for more learning. Students are given the idea that it their elective is a free class a class to do whatever they want for fun. In a lot of cases the elective classes are either taken up by an academic required classic like foreign languages or an academic positive class such as musical instrumentation. For a majority of the student population there elective class is now taken away.. They are not given any options to take classes that would be considered for work related future careers. John Taylor Gatto, in his work article, “Against School” states, “school train children to be employers and consumers; teach your own to think critically and independently." In a recent discussion I had with a cosmetology student, she talked about how she was unable to pick any classes that would relate to her future career in cosmetology while still in high school. There are students who want certain careers that are not usually looked upon as normal careers. Cosmetology is a major industry in the United States, and yet most high schools do not have a program supporting it. A major problem that I have seen in high schools is that when students have a plan of what they would like to do with their lives, with a career in mind, the high schools will not support it. Take the example of a student who wants to become a physicist but still has to take required arts and general history classes, or an art major still is required to take physics or a math class. There are many students who yearn to be an active part in their education and not be lumped into cookie cutter classes. If it wasn't for radical thinkers who strayed away from the norm, we wouldn't have such great and terrible inventions that have change the world. Deciding how classes are to be assigned to students by career choices, needs, and individuality is just again another piece that affects the problem in our education system. There is still one last thing that needs to be overhauled in order to make it a truly revolutionary change that would make it all the better and that change is how students are taught.
Teaching is difficult thing, but to prepare our students for a better tomorrow we must teach our students in a much more efficient manner to prepare them for the challenges that lie before them. Instead of teaching our students childish material we should prepare them with useful skills instead of meaningless knowledge. A good example of this I found was during, Ken Robinson’s Ted talk named, "Education Kills Creativity". He talks about how, “difficult it is to teach children nowadays that we are going to go into a world that we cannot possibly understand what is to come.” I think about all the changes in my lifetime, and the different problems that have come up all over the world these past seventeen years. Change is always happening whether it happens in science, technology or world wars. Teaching adaptation in the school systems must be a priority because we have to prepare them for an enhanced diverse and flexible future. Educators should be taught how to adapt to the changes in technology and the changes in our culture and apply them to educational systems to better connect with students and prepare them for a better learning system, just like how different armies adapted to new technologies and warfare and used it to win battles. As previously stated in Gatto, we must appeal to creativity and independent thinking otherwise we fall into the trap of being afraid of isolation and unable to be at peace with their own selves.
If we do not change, our students will not be educated and not be productive members of our future and we can stop this course of industrialization to our children. It will be difficult to change the way our classrooms work and how the schooling system operates overall. People will want to go back to the old form of education claiming that it is better but, if it was truly better we wouldn't have problems with it. Ken Robinson, John Taylor Gatto, Paolo Freire, and many other educators all agreed that change is needed. For this to happen, all three of the main ideas I have written about must work together. To reach a new era in the world, education must change.
Works Cited
Freire, Paulo. Pedagogy of the Oppressed. New York: Continuum, 2000. Print.
Gatto, John. "Against School - John Taylor Gatto." Against School - John Taylor Gatto. N.p., n.d. Web. 20 Mar. 2014.
Rose, Mike. "I Just Wanna Be Average." Web log post. Http://userwww.sfsu.edu/mmartin/rose.pdf. N.p., n.d. Web. 18 Mar. 2014.
"TED: Ideas worth Spreading." TED: Ideas worth Spreading. N.p., n.d. Web. 20 Mar. 2014.